Saturday, March 8, 2025

Victorious Boxers: Road to Glory – The Ultimate Boxing Simulation(What a Modern Boxer's Road would look like)

A modern version of Victorious Boxers/Boxer’s Road should build upon the foundation of realistic movement, deep career progression, and simulation mechanics while adding modern technology, expanded gameplay modes, and more customization options. Here’s what it could look like:

Core Gameplay & Realism Enhancements

True-to-Life Boxing Mechanics
- Full-body movement system that allows for realistic weight shifts, pivots, and angles.
- Punch physics system that factors in angles, momentum, and stamina.
- Expanded range of punch animations (trajectory, arc, and impact variations).
- Dynamic footwork system inspired by real-life movement tendencies.
- Clinching as a tactical option, with realistic counters.
- Punch variation levels (slight, small, regular, and heavy reactions).
- Realistic slipping, bobbing, weaving, and block styles.
Expanded Stamina and Damage System
- Stamina drain tied to efficiency, experience, and pacing.
- Accumulated damage affects movement, guard, and offensive ability.
- Punch resistance changes based on previous fights (long-term damage system).
- Improved arm fatigue mechanics that reflect different defensive styles.
Knockdown & Knockout System
- Different levels of knockdowns (flash, groggy, struggle to get up, etc.).
- Ropes and corner interactions where fighters can get trapped, tangled, or knocked through.
- Boxers struggling to regain balance after a hard punch.
- Doctor stoppages for cuts, swelling, and severe injuries.

Career Mode (Inspired by Boxer’s Road)

Start as an Amateur or Professional
- Customizable amateur career with multiple tournaments and qualification paths.
- Olympic boxing option with amateur scoring mechanics.
- Option to go pro early or build experience in the amateur ranks.
Dynamic Progression & Aging System
- Boxers improve, decline, or change styles over time.
- Injuries, lifestyle choices, and training affect longevity.
- Players can see different versions of boxers throughout their careers.
Weight Class & Growth System
- Boxers naturally gain or lose weight over time.
- Drastic weight cuts impact stamina, durability, and recovery.
- Open weight options and ability to move across weight classes.
Trainer & Gym Selection
- Different trainers with unique teaching styles, discipline levels, and chemistry effects.
- Gym affiliations matter—some gyms are better for aggressive fighters, others for counterpunchers.
- Ability to switch trainers or create your own boxing stable.
Promotion & Business Aspects
- Sign contracts, negotiate purses, and choose risk vs. reward fights.
- Deal with promoters, sponsors, and potential rivalries.
- Build a reputation through performances, interviews, and rivalries.

Additional Modes

Promoter/Manager Mode
- Run a gym and manage multiple fighters.
- Develop talent, set up sparring sessions, and negotiate contracts.
- Handle financial aspects, promotional deals, and matchmaking.
Story Mode
- Multiple storylines that adapt based on player decisions.
- Play as different roles—boxer, trainer, promoter.
- Deep rivalries and behind-the-scenes interactions.
Broadcast Mode & CPU vs. CPU Simulation
- In-depth simulation of CPU fights with realistic AI tendencies.
- Broadcaster-style presentation similar to NFL 2K5.
Tournaments & Special Events
- Customizable tournaments (single-elimination, round-robin, etc.).
- World Boxing Super Series-inspired format.
- Special crossover fights, open-weight challenges, and historical matchups.

Customization & Creation Suite

Create-A-Boxer (CAB) with Expanded Options
- Deep customization suite with realistic sliders for body type, stance, and movement.
- Expanded gear, outfits, and nickname/name creation (with AI commentary).
- Style editor for creating unique movement, punch, and defensive tendencies.
Custom Weight Divisions & Rulesets
- Ability to modify existing weight classes or create new ones.
- Option to apply different era-based weight divisions.
- Open weight fights and catchweight matches.
Custom Trainers, Gyms, and Officials
- Create legendary or fictional trainers with different specialties.
- Design and customize training facilities.
- Modify referee strictness, judging tendencies, and regional fight styles.

Online & Community Features

Online Career Mode
- Persistent online world where players build their careers against human opponents.
- Gym affiliations and online sparring sessions.
Ranked & Unranked Matches
- Realistic matchmaking based on skill level and weight class.
- Option to play with custom fighters or real fighters.
Cross-Platform Play & Fight Sharing
- Share created boxers, tournaments, and storylines.
- View replays of legendary fights and AI simulations.

Expanded Features for a Modern Version of Victorious Boxers/Boxer’s Road

A modern take on Victorious Boxers/Boxer's Road should build on the strong foundations of movement, realism, and career depth while adding cutting-edge technology, strategic gameplay elements, and fresh game modes that immerse players deeper into the sport.

1. Advanced Gameplay Mechanics

Improved Punching System

Unique delivery mechanics for different punch types (snap, thud, whip, push punches).
Missed punch recovery—punching off-balance or missing too many punches leads to openings.
Power scaling—punch power varies based on distance, foot placement, and momentum.
Realistic counterpunching—not just reaction-based but tied to positioning and anticipation.
Punch visibility mechanics—blind punches (not seeing the punch coming) have higher impact.
Proper inside-fighting mechanics, allowing realistic shoulder rolls, clinch tactics, and short-range attacks.

Realistic Footwork & Stance Adjustments

Live foot adjustments—boxers must set their feet to generate power properly.
Directional weight shifting—cut off the ring, pivot in real time, and use angles effectively.
Refined loose footwork system—only fighters known for fluid movement can use it effectively.
Multi-angle stance variations—fighters can slightly alter their stance for offensive or defensive preferences.

Refined Defensive Mechanics

Adaptive blocking—blocking changes based on stamina, reflexes, and habits.
Feints and micro-movements—use subtle body and hand movements to create openings.
Realistic roll damage absorption—rolling with punches reduces damage but requires timing.
Glove positioning matters—high guard vs. cross guard vs. peek-a-boo all have unique strengths/weaknesses.

Grappling & Clinching System

Strategic clinching—boxers with certain styles can clinch effectively to recover stamina.
Referee intervention mechanics—refs warn fighters for excessive holding.
Dirty boxing options—fighters can work on the inside with short uppercuts, punches in the clinch, or forearm control.

Damage & Recovery System

Gradual deterioration of durability—fighters accumulate damage over multiple fights.
Long-term injury system—persistent damage affects future fights and career longevity.
Realistic eye and cut damage—doctors can stop fights if injuries worsen.
Rope entanglement & stumble physics—fighters can get caught in the ropes or fall when off balance.

2. Ultimate Career Mode

A true-to-life boxing career experience with full control over a fighter’s journey from amateur to professional ranks.

Amateur to Pro Pipeline

Deep amateur system with Olympic boxing, regional tournaments, and national championships.
Alternate career paths—fighters can start in different regions with different boxing cultures.
Diverse debut options—turn pro early, take developmental fights, or become a journeyman.
Hidden gems and late bloomers—not all fighters peak at the same time; some improve with experience.

Weight Management & Body Development

Fighters naturally gain/lose weight—metabolism, training, and diet impact weight class movement.
Weight cutting and its effects—extreme cuts reduce stamina and durability.
Unique training for muscle mass, endurance, or weight maintenance.

Training Camp System

Multi-phase training camps—divided into strength, technical, endurance, and sparring phases.
Customized sparring—choose sparring partners based on opponent styles.
Coach and trainer interactions—some trainers focus on power, others on speed, defense, or strategy.
Camp injuries and adjustments—sparring too hard can lead to injuries before fights.

Dynamic Opponent AI & Career Paths

Opponent AI evolves—fighters adapt based on previous fights against you.
Multi-fight rivalries—facing an opponent multiple times creates new wrinkles in the fight.
Changing world rankings and shifting opportunities—unexpected upsets, new prospects rising.
Style evolution—fighters change styles as they age or switch trainers.

3. Expanded Story & RPG Elements

Narrative-Based Story Mode

Dynamic career narratives—the story changes based on decisions (e.g., aggressive negotiations, taking easy fights, or chasing glory).
Fighter personality system—humble vs. cocky, media-friendly vs. reserved.
Media interactions & interviews—build rivalries, gain fans, or alienate the boxing world.
Backroom politics—promoters, managers, and sanctioning bodies play a role in career progression.
Realistic financial system—fighters go broke without proper money management.

Branching Fighter Paths

Championship pursuit—build a legacy, unify belts, or aim for undisputed status.
Journeyman survival—fight for paychecks, take dangerous fights, and survive in the sport.
Brawler vs. Technician—player choices dictate how a fighter’s style develops.

4. Additional Game Modes

Promoter/Manager Mode

Control a stable of fighters—sign, train, and promote boxers.
Manage contracts, negotiations, and matchmaking.
Develop gym reputation—attract talent, hire trainers, and improve facilities.

Broadcast & AI Simulation Mode

CPU vs. CPU realism—watch fights unfold based on styles, stamina, and tactics.
Fight breakdowns & statistical analysis—view punch stats, landed shots, and tendencies.
Tournament creator with realistic AI progression.

Legends & Historical Fights

Recreate legendary fights from boxing history.
Fight across different eras with era-accurate rules, gloves, and presentation.

5. Ultimate Customization & Community Features

Creation Suite

Create-A-Boxer with next-gen details—scars, tattoos, body shape sliders.
Create custom styles, stances, and movement tendencies.
Full gear customization—gloves, trunks, shoes, and robe details.

Custom Weight Divisions & Rules

Modify existing divisions or create your own weight classes.
Allow open-weight fights or custom fight stipulations.

Online & Community Integration

Online fighter rankings based on skill, not just wins/losses.
Global player-run fight leagues and tournaments.
Cross-platform play for maximum matchmaking.
Fight sharing and highlight clips for replay value.

Final Thoughts

A modern version of Victorious Boxers/Boxer's Road should expand on realistic boxing mechanics, career depth, and customization while incorporating modern AI, physics-based gameplay, and online integration. With next-gen graphics, improved fight physics, and a deep RPG-driven career, this could be the ultimate boxing simulation experience, setting a new standard for the genre.

Is Undisputed Dead?

**Is Undisputed Dead?**

The anticipation surrounding Undisputed, formerly known as eSports Boxing Club (ESBC), was once at an all-time high. Positioned as the first major boxing simulation game, it promised realism, depth, and an experience that boxing fans had long been craving. However, as time has passed and early access has continued with limited major updates, many are beginning to question: Is Undisputed dead?

A Promising Start That Fizzled?

When Undisputed was first announced, it generated massive excitement. Steel City Interactive (SCI) marketed the game as the most authentic boxing simulation ever created, boasting a roster filled with legends, an advanced footwork system, and highly detailed visuals. The initial trailers and gameplay footage fueled expectations that Undisputed could be the boxing game fans had waited decades for.

However, as early access continued, enthusiasm began to wane. Players started noticing issues that contradicted the game’s promise of realism. The punch variety was limited, the mechanics lacked fluidity, and fundamental aspects of boxing—such as proper defensive tools, inside fighting, and strategic AI—felt underdeveloped. Instead of refining its foundation, Undisputed began introducing questionable changes that moved it further from its original vision.

Where Did Things Go Wrong?

1. Early Access Fatigue

One of the biggest problems Undisputed faces is its prolonged early access phase. Early access can be beneficial, allowing developers to fine-tune their game based on community feedback. However, when updates slow down and the core gameplay fails to evolve significantly, it can leave players disillusioned. Many in the boxing gaming community have grown impatient, feeling as though SCI is not addressing the key concerns that would make Undisputed a true simulation.

2. Lack of a Clear Vision

Initially, Undisputed was marketed as the most realistic boxing game ever made. However, as development progressed, it became clear that the game was drifting toward a hybrid approach—one that attempted to balance realism with accessibility. This shift alienated hardcore boxing fans, who had supported the game based on its original promise of authenticity. The introduction of mechanics that felt more arcade-like, such as exaggerated stamina drain and limited defensive control, further frustrated players.

3. Inconsistent Gameplay Mechanics

While Undisputed boasts certain impressive mechanics—such as its footwork system and punch variety—its overall gameplay remains inconsistent. The punch impact lacks the weight and variety needed to reflect real boxing. Fighters often react unrealistically to strikes, and knockdowns feel scripted rather than dynamic. Additionally, some fighters have been given unrealistic abilities, with certain boxers moving in ways that do not align with their real-life counterparts.

4. Defensive Options Are Lacking

One of the most glaring issues with Undisputed is its weak defensive system. Boxing is just as much about defense as it is about offense, yet the game severely limits defensive tools. The blocking system is basic, and head movement is often ineffective. There is no real emphasis on different defensive styles, such as the Philly Shell, cross-armed defense, or the peek-a-boo style. Without a nuanced defensive system, fights often become slugfests rather than strategic battles.

5. Limited Inside Fighting Mechanics

Inside fighting is a crucial part of boxing, yet Undisputed has not been able to replicate it properly. Clinching is minimal, body shots lack impact, and there is no true infighting system where fighters can work on the inside effectively. Boxers who excel in close-quarters combat in real life, such as Joe Frazier or Mike Tyson, do not fight as they should in the game. This oversight removes an entire layer of strategy that should exist in a boxing simulation.

6. Career Mode and Offline Depth Are Underdeveloped

One of the biggest disappointments for many players is the lack of offline depth. Career mode, a crucial component for any sports simulation, remains largely underdeveloped. There is no true sense of progression, no deep customization options, and no elements that truly immerse the player in a boxer’s journey. There is no proper amateur system, no Olympic pathway, and no option to turn pro at different stages in a career. Without a compelling single-player experience, Undisputed feels like an incomplete game, especially for those who are not interested in online competition.

7. A Declining Player Base

Perhaps the most telling sign that Undisputed is struggling is its player base. When the game first launched in early access, it attracted a healthy number of players eager to test its mechanics. However, as time went on and updates failed to address major concerns, many players moved on. A game with a shrinking community—especially one reliant on online play—faces an uncertain future.

**Can Undisputed Be Saved?**

Despite its struggles, Undisputed is not necessarily dead—at least, not yet. The game still has potential, but it would require SCI to refocus on the core principles that made it appealing in the first place.

**What Undisputed Needs to Do to Survive:**

Commit to True Simulation – SCI must decide whether Undisputed is a true boxing simulation or an arcade hybrid. If realism is the goal, mechanics must be refined to reflect actual boxing strategy, movement, and physics.
Improve Punch Mechanics and Impact – Punches need more variety, better physics, and realistic reactions. The feeling of hitting an opponent should be satisfying, and knockdowns should be more organic.
Expand Defensive Options – Right now, defense feels underdeveloped. There should be a variety of blocking styles, more effective counters, and a better inside fighting system.
Develop a Real Inside Fighting System – Boxing is not just about fighting from a distance. Infighting, clinching, and mid-range exchanges should be fleshed out to reflect the different styles of real fighters.
Revamp Career Mode – If Undisputed wants to keep players engaged, it needs a compelling career mode with deep customization, rankings, stables, promoters, and a true sense of progression.
Fix AI and CPU vs. CPU Mechanics – AI should reflect real-life tendencies, and fighters should have unique styles. Watching two CPU fighters should feel like watching a real fight, not just a basic exchange of punches.
Listen to Hardcore Fans – The people who championed Undisputed from the beginning were hardcore boxing fans who wanted a true-to-life boxing simulation. Their feedback should shape the game's future, rather than chasing a broader audience at the expense of realism.

Conclusion: The Future of Undisputed

So, is Undisputed dead? Not entirely. However, it is at a crossroads. If SCI continues on its current path—failing to address core gameplay issues and alienating its original fanbase—then Undisputed may fade into obscurity like other failed boxing games before it.

However, if the developers take the necessary steps to refocus on realism, improve mechanics, and deliver a polished career mode, Undisputed still has a chance to become the definitive boxing simulation fans have been waiting for.

The question now is: Will Steel City Interactive rise to the challenge, or will Undisputed become just another missed opportunity in boxing gaming history?

Is Undisputed Dead?

**Is Undisputed Dead?**

A Promising Start That Fizzled?

Where Did Things Go Wrong?

1. Early Access Fatigue

2. Lack of a Clear Vision

3. Inconsistent Gameplay Mechanics

4. Defensive Options Are Lacking

5. Limited Inside Fighting Mechanics

6. Career Mode and Offline Depth Are Underdeveloped

7. A Declining Player Base

**Can Undisputed Be Saved?**

**What Undisputed Needs to Do to Survive:**

Commit to True Simulation – SCI must decide whether Undisputed is a true boxing simulation or an arcade hybrid. If realism is the goal, mechanics must be refined to reflect actual boxing strategy, movement, and physics.
Improve Punch Mechanics and Impact – Punches need more variety, better physics, and realistic reactions. The feeling of hitting an opponent should be satisfying, and knockdowns should be more organic.
Expand Defensive Options – Right now, defense feels underdeveloped. There should be a variety of blocking styles, more effective counters, and a better inside fighting system.
Develop a Real Inside Fighting System – Boxing is not just about fighting from a distance. Infighting, clinching, and mid-range exchanges should be fleshed out to reflect the different styles of real fighters.
Revamp Career Mode – If Undisputed wants to keep players engaged, it needs a compelling career mode with deep customization, rankings, stables, promoters, and a true sense of progression.
Fix AI and CPU vs. CPU Mechanics – AI should reflect real-life tendencies, and fighters should have unique styles. Watching two CPU fighters should feel like watching a real fight, not just a basic exchange of punches.
Listen to Hardcore Fans – The people who championed Undisputed from the beginning were hardcore boxing fans who wanted a true-to-life boxing simulation. Their feedback should shape the game's future, rather than chasing a broader audience at the expense of realism.

Conclusion: The Future of Undisputed

The question now is: Will Steel City Interactive rise to the challenge, or will Undisputed become just another missed opportunity in boxing gaming history?

Friday, March 7, 2025

Boxers and Trainers Must Speak Up About the State of Boxing Video Games

Boxers and Trainers Must Speak Up About the State of Boxing Video Games

The silence from professional boxers and trainers regarding the development of modern boxing video games is deafening. When a game is being created to represent their sport, their voices should be the loudest in the room. Yet, for reasons unknown, they remain largely absent from the conversation.

A rumor has circulated that Steel City Interactive (SCI), the developers of Undisputed, stopped having boxers actively involved in the studio early in development. This speculation seems to hold some weight, as many of the realistic boxing mechanics that fans initially praised are now either absent or significantly altered. The foundation of what could have been a truly groundbreaking simulation of the sport is slowly shifting toward an arcade-style fighting game instead of an authentic boxing experience.

When Undisputed was first introduced to the public under its early moniker, eSports Boxing Club (ESBC), it was heralded as the next big leap in boxing gaming. The mechanics showcased during the early phases appeared to emphasize realism—footwork, punch trajectories, defensive maneuvers, and the nuanced tactics that make boxing a chess match inside the ring. Fans assumed the game would continue to evolve, refining these mechanics and building upon its solid groundwork. Instead, what has transpired feels like a regression.

The removal or alteration of key mechanics suggests that someone within the studio either lacks an understanding of what boxing truly is or has deliberately pushed the game in a more arcade-friendly direction. The troubling part is that this transition happened after boxers were reportedly no longer being consulted in the development process. Could it be that without their direct input, the game is losing its authenticity? It certainly appears so.

Professional fighters and trainers who play video games should be among the most vocal critics and advocates for the genre. They are the ones who know the intricacies of the sport, who can spot what Undisputed gets right and what it gets wrong. They should be the ones demanding that a boxing game actually reflect boxing. Without their input, there is a risk that Undisputed will continue to move further away from realism and closer to being just another arcade fighter with a boxing skin.

If the rumors about SCI’s development direction are true, it is a major cause for concern. The industry has already suffered from a lack of high-quality boxing titles for years, and the last thing fans need is another misstep. It is crucial for boxers, trainers, and dedicated fans of the sport to raise their voices. If the development team is straying from realism, the boxing community needs to hold them accountable. Otherwise, boxing games may continue to be watered down, leaving fans longing for a true simulation that may never come.

Adding to the frustration is the fact that SCI initially promised innovation and realism, something that drew in hardcore boxing fans eager for a true representation of the sport. However, over time, many of those promises have been eroded or outright abandoned. Features that once looked like game-changers have either been removed or replaced with mechanics that prioritize accessibility over authenticity. This shift raises an important question—was the original vision for Undisputed compromised by external pressures, or was the commitment to realism never as strong as fans were led to believe?

The consequences of a misstep in development are far-reaching. If Undisputed veers too far into arcade territory, it could discourage future developers from attempting a true boxing simulation. Investors and publishers may see the genre as unviable, believing that fans prefer an arcade experience rather than the deep, tactical gameplay that boxing truly requires. This is why it's imperative for fans, boxers, and trainers alike to push back against these changes and demand a game that does justice to the sport.

Another troubling aspect of this shift is the exclusion of passionate boxing fans from discussions and online communities. Many dedicated fans who voiced concerns about realism being sacrificed have been pushed out of groups and forums where these discussions take place. This has created an echo chamber that favors a more casual, arcade-style experience while silencing those who want an authentic boxing game. Instead of embracing constructive criticism, it seems like certain spaces have actively worked to suppress it, making it even more difficult for realism to remain a priority in development.

If the developers still care about realism, they need to bring boxers and trainers back into the conversation. They need to listen to those who understand the sport at its deepest levels. Otherwise, Undisputed risks becoming yet another cautionary tale of what happens when developers lose sight of their original vision. The time to speak up is now before it's too late.

Boxers and Trainers Must Speak Up About the State of Boxing Video Games

Boxers and Trainers Must Speak Up About the State of Boxing Video Games

Tuesday, March 4, 2025

SCI Can Learn from NBA 2K’s Success by Hiring Hardcore Boxing Fans and Industry Experts

SCI Can Learn from NBA 2K’s Success by Hiring Hardcore Boxing Fans and Industry Experts

Steel City Interactive (SCI), the developers behind Undisputed, are facing growing scrutiny from boxing fans regarding the state of their game. Many are questioning whether the company has made the right hiring choices, as the game continues to struggle with mechanics, realism, and core gameplay elements that should reflect the sport of boxing. Fans are pointing to the success of NBA 2K as a model for how a boxing game should be built—by hiring individuals deeply connected to the sport, including hardcore fans, former boxers, trainers, and industry professionals.

The NBA 2K Blueprint for Success

One of the key reasons NBA 2K has remained the premier basketball simulation for years is its commitment to realism. Visual Concepts, the developer of NBA 2K, has consistently hired former NBA players, analysts, and basketball enthusiasts who understand the nuances of the sport. They bring expertise that helps shape gameplay mechanics, player tendencies, and game modes in ways that feel authentic to fans. By integrating these experts into the development process, NBA 2K ensures that the gameplay reflects the actual sport, making it an engaging and rewarding experience for players.

SCI’s Hiring Choices Raise Concerns

In contrast, SCI’s hiring decisions have left many boxing fans perplexed. While some hires may have industry experience, it’s unclear if they possess a true passion for or deep knowledge of boxing. The result? A game that feels disconnected from the sport it’s trying to simulate. Undisputed has received criticism for unrealistic movement, awkward punch mechanics, and gameplay that often ignores fundamental boxing strategies. Fans are now questioning whether these issues stem from a lack of true boxing minds in the development process.

Why Hiring Hardcore Boxing Fans and Industry Experts Matters

Understanding of the Sport – Hardcore boxing fans and industry experts know what makes boxing unique. They understand the importance of feints, defensive maneuvers, stamina management, and realistic punch trajectories. This knowledge is crucial for developing an authentic boxing simulation.
Player Tendencies and Styles – Just as NBA 2K replicates the playing styles of real basketball players, a boxing game should ensure that real-life fighters have accurate tendencies and behaviors. Hiring trainers, boxers, and analysts would help SCI capture these details.
Game Balance and Mechanics – Having people who truly know boxing can prevent developers from implementing arcade-style mechanics that alienate fans of the sport. A sim-based boxing game requires deep understanding, not just generic fight animations.
Community Trust and Engagement – When fans see that developers respect and understand the sport, they are more likely to support the game long-term. Having well-known and respected figures from the boxing world involved in development can build credibility and trust.

The Current State of Undisputed

The criticism of Undisputed largely stems from the gameplay not meeting expectations for a realistic boxing simulation. Issues such as unnatural footwork, repetitive animations, questionable stamina management, and unbalanced mechanics are frustrating players. These flaws suggest that the team behind the game lacks a deep understanding of boxing fundamentals.

While SCI has attempted to engage with the community and take feedback, their response time and execution have been inconsistent. Many believe that hiring more knowledgeable individuals would help bridge the gap between what fans expect and what SCI is currently delivering.

What SCI Should Do Moving Forward

Hire Hardcore Boxing Fans – Passionate fans who understand the sport will advocate for the details that make boxing unique.
Bring in Boxing Experts – Trainers, former fighters, and analysts can provide valuable insights on mechanics and realism.
Study Successful Sports Games – Following NBA 2K’s approach of using real-world expertise can elevate Undisputed to the next level.
Listen to the Community – The fans have been vocal about what they want, and SCI needs to acknowledge and implement their feedback properly.

Conclusion

SCI has an opportunity to create the definitive boxing simulation, but that will only happen if they take the right approach. By following in the footsteps of NBA 2K and hiring individuals who live and breathe boxing, they can refine Undisputed into the game that boxing fans have been waiting for. The blueprint for success is there—SCI just needs to follow it.

SCI Can Learn from NBA 2K’s Success by Hiring Hardcore Boxing Fans and Industry Experts

SCI Can Learn from NBA 2K’s Success by Hiring Hardcore Boxing Fans and Industry Experts

The NBA 2K Blueprint for Success

SCI’s Hiring Choices Raise Concerns

Why Hiring Hardcore Boxing Fans and Industry Experts Matters

Understanding of the Sport – Hardcore boxing fans and industry experts know what makes boxing unique. They understand the importance of feints, defensive maneuvers, stamina management, and realistic punch trajectories. This knowledge is crucial for developing an authentic boxing simulation.
Player Tendencies and Styles – Just as NBA 2K replicates the playing styles of real basketball players, a boxing game should ensure that real-life fighters have accurate tendencies and behaviors. Hiring trainers, boxers, and analysts would help SCI capture these details.
Game Balance and Mechanics – Having people who truly know boxing can prevent developers from implementing arcade-style mechanics that alienate fans of the sport. A sim-based boxing game requires deep understanding, not just generic fight animations.
Community Trust and Engagement – When fans see that developers respect and understand the sport, they are more likely to support the game long-term. Having well-known and respected figures from the boxing world involved in development can build credibility and trust.

The Current State of Undisputed

What SCI Should Do Moving Forward

Hire Hardcore Boxing Fans – Passionate fans who understand the sport will advocate for the details that make boxing unique.
Bring in Boxing Experts – Trainers, former fighters, and analysts can provide valuable insights on mechanics and realism.
Study Successful Sports Games – Following NBA 2K’s approach of using real-world expertise can elevate Undisputed to the next level.
Listen to the Community – The fans have been vocal about what they want, and SCI needs to acknowledge and implement their feedback properly.

Conclusion

Creating a realistic boxing video game requires...

Creating a realistic boxing video game requires a well-structured development team with expertise in multiple disciplines to ensure authenticity in gameplay, visuals, AI, and presentation. Here’s how a company should structure its development team:

1. Leadership & Production Team

Game Director – Oversees the vision and execution of the game, ensuring it aligns with realism and authenticity.
Executive Producer – Manages timelines, budget, and resources while ensuring smooth communication across teams.
Project Managers – Handle scheduling, task assignments, and team coordination.

2. Game Design Team

Lead Game Designer – Ensures the game mechanics, controls, and overall gameplay align with realistic boxing.
Gameplay Designers – Focus on mechanics such as movement, punch variations, clinching, blocking, counters, and AI.
AI Designers – Develop a system that makes boxers fight according to their real-life tendencies or specific styles.
Camera & Presentation Designers – Work on realistic broadcast-style angles, replays, ring walks, and presentation features.
UI/UX Designers – Ensure an intuitive and immersive experience for menus, HUD, and fight statistics.

3. Animation & Motion Team

Animation Director – Oversees movement and punch animations for fluidity and realism.
Animators – Create lifelike movements for punches, footwork, defensive maneuvers, knockdowns, and reactions.
Motion Capture Specialists – Capture realistic movements, but should also incorporate AI-driven physics-based animation (optional for realism).
Procedural Animation Engineers – Develop real-time physics-driven movements for better transitions and organic reactions.

4. Art & Visual Team

Art Director – Ensures the visual fidelity of character models, arenas, lighting, and textures.
Character Artists – Create highly detailed boxer models with realistic textures, skin tones, and facial animations.
Environmental Artists – Design arenas, gyms, locker rooms, and other backgrounds.
Lighting & VFX Artists – Enhance realism with proper lighting, sweat effects, blood physics, and impact visuals.

5. Audio Team

Audio Director – Oversees sound design for immersion.
Sound Engineers – Develop realistic punch sounds, breathing, crowd reactions, and environmental audio.
Commentary & Voice Designers – Record and integrate realistic, dynamic commentary and boxer grunts/reactions.
Ring Announcers & Referees Audio Team – Record authentic referee commands and ring announcer introductions.

6. Engineering & AI Development Team

Lead Engineer – Oversees technical implementation and game engine optimization.
Gameplay Programmers – Code the boxing mechanics, movement, hit detection, physics, and stamina systems.
AI Programmers – Develop intelligent, adaptable AI that mimics real boxing strategies and tendencies.
Physics Programmers – Work on ragdoll effects, punch impact physics, foot planting, and rope interactions.
Online & Networking Engineers – Ensure smooth online matchmaking, lag reduction, and ranked/unranked modes.

7. Boxing Consultants & Research Team

Boxing Trainers & Experts – Advise on realistic movement, strategies, and tendencies.
Professional Boxers – Provide feedback on feel, mechanics, and realism.
Cutmen & Referees – Ensure authentic representation of in-game stoppages, cuts, and referee interventions.
Statisticians & Historians – Ensure accurate rankings, records, and fighter attributes.

8. Quality Assurance (QA) & Playtesting

QA Testers – Identify and report bugs, glitches, and inconsistencies.
Playtesters – Evaluate realism and authenticity in gameplay mechanics.
Balance & Tuning Team – Ensure that different boxer styles, strengths, and weaknesses are properly balanced.

9. Marketing & Community Engagement

Marketing Director – Plans the promotion strategy.
Social Media & Community Managers – Engage with fans and take feedback.
Content Creators & Influencers – Partner with boxing gaming enthusiasts for outreach.

By structuring the development team this way, the company can ensure that the game is an authentic representation of boxing while being polished, balanced, and immersive.

Creating a realistic boxing video game requires...

1. Leadership & Production Team

Game Director – Oversees the vision and execution of the game, ensuring it aligns with realism and authenticity.
Executive Producer – Manages timelines, budget, and resources while ensuring smooth communication across teams.
Project Managers – Handle scheduling, task assignments, and team coordination.

2. Game Design Team

Lead Game Designer – Ensures the game mechanics, controls, and overall gameplay align with realistic boxing.
Gameplay Designers – Focus on mechanics such as movement, punch variations, clinching, blocking, counters, and AI.
AI Designers – Develop a system that makes boxers fight according to their real-life tendencies or specific styles.
Camera & Presentation Designers – Work on realistic broadcast-style angles, replays, ring walks, and presentation features.
UI/UX Designers – Ensure an intuitive and immersive experience for menus, HUD, and fight statistics.

3. Animation & Motion Team

Animation Director – Oversees movement and punch animations for fluidity and realism.
Animators – Create lifelike movements for punches, footwork, defensive maneuvers, knockdowns, and reactions.
Motion Capture Specialists – Capture realistic movements, but should also incorporate AI-driven physics-based animation (optional for realism).
Procedural Animation Engineers – Develop real-time physics-driven movements for better transitions and organic reactions.

4. Art & Visual Team

Art Director – Ensures the visual fidelity of character models, arenas, lighting, and textures.
Character Artists – Create highly detailed boxer models with realistic textures, skin tones, and facial animations.
Environmental Artists – Design arenas, gyms, locker rooms, and other backgrounds.
Lighting & VFX Artists – Enhance realism with proper lighting, sweat effects, blood physics, and impact visuals.

5. Audio Team

Audio Director – Oversees sound design for immersion.
Sound Engineers – Develop realistic punch sounds, breathing, crowd reactions, and environmental audio.
Commentary & Voice Designers – Record and integrate realistic, dynamic commentary and boxer grunts/reactions.
Ring Announcers & Referees Audio Team – Record authentic referee commands and ring announcer introductions.

6. Engineering & AI Development Team

Lead Engineer – Oversees technical implementation and game engine optimization.
Gameplay Programmers – Code the boxing mechanics, movement, hit detection, physics, and stamina systems.
AI Programmers – Develop intelligent, adaptable AI that mimics real boxing strategies and tendencies.
Physics Programmers – Work on ragdoll effects, punch impact physics, foot planting, and rope interactions.
Online & Networking Engineers – Ensure smooth online matchmaking, lag reduction, and ranked/unranked modes.

7. Boxing Consultants & Research Team

Boxing Trainers & Experts – Advise on realistic movement, strategies, and tendencies.
Professional Boxers – Provide feedback on feel, mechanics, and realism.
Cutmen & Referees – Ensure authentic representation of in-game stoppages, cuts, and referee interventions.
Statisticians & Historians – Ensure accurate rankings, records, and fighter attributes.

8. Quality Assurance (QA) & Playtesting

QA Testers – Identify and report bugs, glitches, and inconsistencies.
Playtesters – Evaluate realism and authenticity in gameplay mechanics.
Balance & Tuning Team – Ensure that different boxer styles, strengths, and weaknesses are properly balanced.

9. Marketing & Community Engagement

Marketing Director – Plans the promotion strategy.
Social Media & Community Managers – Engage with fans and take feedback.
Content Creators & Influencers – Partner with boxing gaming enthusiasts for outreach.

By structuring the development team this way, the company can ensure that the game is an authentic representation of boxing while being polished, balanced, and immersive.

Monday, March 3, 2025

The Sad Attempt to Silence a Passionate Boxing Video Game Advocate

The boxing video game community has long been starved for a truly immersive and realistic experience. With no major simulation boxing game released in over a decade, fans have been left clinging to hopes and promises, often disappointed by underwhelming attempts. But within this void, a few voices have risen to champion the cause of a deep, realistic, and simulation-driven boxing experience. One such voice—arguably the most relentless and passionate—has been under attack simply for pushing the industry to do better.

A Voice for the Boxing Gaming Community

Poeticdrink2u (Poe) has been one of the loudest, most consistent advocates for a true-to-life boxing video game, demanding that developers respect the sport and its intricacies. His push for realism isn’t just about making a game look good but ensuring that it feels like the sport—where every punch, every feint, and every defensive maneuver matters. He envisions a game where tendencies, styles, movement, and reactions reflect real-life boxing, rather than a watered-down arcade experience disguised as a simulation.

While some in the gaming industry focus on marketability and accessibility, Poe has never wavered from his stance that a boxing game should cater first and foremost to boxing fans—those who appreciate the sport's depth and nuance. This unwavering passion has made him a target for those who would rather silence criticism than improve the product.

The Movement to Shut Him Down

Instead of engaging in meaningful dialogue, some have resorted to dismissing or outright silencing his voice. The reasons are telling:

He Challenges the Status Quo – Poe’s detailed breakdowns of what makes a boxing game truly immersive expose the shortcuts and compromises that developers often make. Some people don’t want to hear that the “simulation” they are promoting is missing critical elements.
He Refuses to Be Complacent – While many settle for what’s given, Poe keeps pushing. He doesn’t believe in excuses like “it’s too hard to develop” or “casuals won’t understand.” His argument is simple: if the technology exists, why not use it?
He Won’t Let Companies Rebrand Mediocrity as Realism – In the gaming industry, companies often slap a “simulation” label on a product that barely scratches the surface of authenticity. Poe has called this out repeatedly, making it harder for these companies to sell their games on empty promises.

Because of this, his voice is being drowned out by a movement that would rather see a compromised, mass-market-friendly game than a deep, fully realized boxing simulation. Some dismiss him as "too demanding" or "never satisfied," but the reality is that he represents an entire community that is tired of being ignored.

The Importance of Unwavering Advocacy

If history has taught us anything, it’s that real progress comes from those unwilling to accept mediocrity. The greatest sports games—titles like NFL 2K5, Fight Night Champion, and NBA 2K in its prime—were built by developers who pushed boundaries, not by those who played it safe.

The attempt to silence a voice like Poe’s is an attempt to silence the very essence of what makes gaming communities great: passionate players who demand excellence. His critiques aren’t meant to tear down games but to build something better. The developers who listen—who take the challenge seriously—will be the ones who create a game that stands the test of time.

The Real Fight: Passion vs. Complacency

At its core, this is a battle between passion and complacency. Should the boxing video game community settle for yet another half-baked attempt, or should they rally behind those who are fighting for something greater? If a game is truly good, it should be able to withstand scrutiny. If it can’t, maybe it’s not as great as some claim.

The movement to silence Poe is a sad reflection of an industry that too often prioritizes quick sales over lasting quality. But boxing fans and gamers alike should remember: it’s the voices that demand more that ultimately bring about real change.

And that’s why Poe should never be silenced.