1. Legacy Execution vs Modern Limitations
Boxer's Road (1995–2000s, PSP/PS1):
-
Fighter falls where they are hit (backward, sideways, into ropes, etc.)
-
Get-up attempts happen wherever the boxer lands – against ropes, near corners, etc.
-
Falling direction is affected by momentum, position, and hit type.
-
Ragdoll-like behavior or animated transitions mimicked real physics.
Undisputed (2023–2025):
-
Boxer always teleports to the center of the ring for knockdowns and get-up mini-games.
-
No rope interactions during knockdowns.
-
Fall directions are preset animations, disconnected from the fight context.
2. Technical Breakdown: Why Boxer's Road Did It Better
| Feature | Boxer’s Road | Undisputed |
|---|---|---|
| Fall Location | Wherever the punch lands | Center of ring (forced teleport) |
| Knockdown Variants | Multiple contextual knockdowns | Pre-canned, center-locked |
| Get-Up System | Ground-position-based, camera adapts | Standard front-facing center camera |
| Ropes/Corner Physics | Used in a fall impact | Ignored during KDs |
| Immersion Factor | High realism, situational | Broken immersion due to teleporting |
3. Why Modern Games Like Undisputed Fail at This
Design Choices or Oversight?
-
Focus may have been on competitive esports-style consistency, not realism.
-
A "safe zone" (center ring) is likely used to avoid:
-
Camera clipping
-
Rope collision bugs
-
Hard-to-code dynamic get-up angles
-
-
Possible rushed animation system:
-
Only animating get-ups from one spot was faster to implement.
-
4. But If Boxer’s Road Could Do It… Why Can’t They?
A. Prioritized Simulation, Not Flash
-
Developers built everything around the boxing match logic, not esports systems.
-
Even on weaker hardware, they simulated:
-
Boxers tangled in ropes.
-
Falling in corners.
-
Realistic stagger before falling.
-
B. Modern Excuses Don’t Hold Up
-
Boxer’s Road is over 20 years old.
-
Today’s game engines (Unity, Unreal) can handle:
-
Physics-based ragdoll + pose matching.
-
Spline-based camera tracking.
-
Ropes as soft bodies with collision.
-
5. What Should Undisputed Do Instead?
Realistic Knockdown System Blueprint:
-
Fall logic:
-
Match the punch angle + momentum.
-
Rope/corner detection.
-
-
Get-up mini-game location:
-
Happens where the boxer fell, not a fake location.
-
-
Camera:
-
Dynamic follow with corner/rope logic.
-
-
Visual cues:
-
If a boxer is tangled or trapped near ropes, have a “ref struggles to clear space” animation.
-
6. Why It Matters to Boxing Fans
-
Realism breeds immersion, not frustration.
-
If a boxer goes down face-first near the ropes, the scene should reflect that. It raises the stakes.
-
Real boxing fans notice when the boxer falls in one spot but magically reappears somewhere else.
-
It breaks the emotional and visual rhythm of the match.
Conclusion:
Older games like Boxer’s Road had less power, but more respect for the sport’s detail. Undisputed needs to stop relying on "tech excuse culture" and fix its disconnected get-up/fall system, or it’ll continue breaking immersion for the very fans it was supposed to honor.
No comments:
Post a Comment